Pre-Experimental Wet Heat Sterilization Alters the Ecotoxicity of Pristine Graphene Oxide Toward Daphnia magna

Abstract

As the exposure of the aquatic ecosystem to graphene oxide (GO) increases with its growing production and use, understanding the structure–property–toxicity relationships becomes increasingly critical in the development of effective safe design guidelines. An appropriate testing methodology is crucial in ecotoxicity assessments to accurately characterize the environmentally relevant toxicity of nanoparticles, particularly for GO, where the physicochemical properties fundamentally determine their interactions and toxicity toward aquatic organisms. Many ecotoxicological methods require the heat sterilization of samples as a preliminary treatment prior to analysis. To investigate changes in toxicity profiles induced by wet heat sterilization pretreatments (autoclaving and Tyndall treatment) of a well-characterized GO product, a comprehensive ecotoxicological evaluation was performed with Daphnia magna. This included conventional lethality and immobilization tests, along with sublethal endpoints such as heart rate and feeding activity, supplemented with the analysis of oxidative stress biomarkers. Physicochemical alterations in GO due to sterilization were examined with dynamic light scattering, ultraviolet-visible, and thermogravimetry/mass spectrometry. Sublethal endpoints were shown to be more sensitive indicators of toxicity than conventional methods, with feeding activity and heart rate inhibition demonstrating time and concentration-dependent effects. Heat-sterilized GOs exhibited greater ecotoxicity compared to pristine GO, as evidenced by elevated ROS levels and increased oxidative stress biomarkers (GPx and GST activities), implicating oxidative stress as a central mechanism of toxicity. Despite the subtle differences observed in the physicochemical properties, the impact of heat sterilization on toxicity is clear. Our research underscores the critical importance of adopting appropriate testing and evaluation methodologies for comparing GO ecotoxicity results under axenic and non-axenic conditions as well as a multimarker approach to accurately evaluate the risks posed by GO.